Archives

All posts for the month June, 2013

UPA/ Gandhi Vs NDA/Modi… Ek taraf uska ghar, ek taraf maikadaa…

Published June 28, 2013 by vishalvkale

Zindagi ek hai aur talabgaar do
Jaan akeli magar jaan ke huqdaar do
dil bataa pehle kiskaa karoon huq adaa
Ek taraf uskaa ghar ek taraf maikadaa
Is talluq ko main kaise todun zafar
kisko apnau main kisko chhodun zafar
meraa dono se rishtaa hai nazdeek kaa
Ek taraf uskaa ghar ek taraf maikadaa


The immediate aftermath of the sad Uttarakhand tragedy has highlighted aspects of both sides of the political spectrum which are disturbing; while you have the Modi phenomenon with the much-touted “help-Gujarati only” approach, with intervention in the middle of a tragedy; and Rahul Gandhi and his Z-Plus security visit which forced a closure of an ITBP location… leaving me wondering: who to choose, on whose side to go, who to vote for – or is it that none of these is deserving of my vote… the only weapon I have to express my desires and my aspirations!

THE FIRST SIDE
First, let us take the famous Modi rescue mission. Having read both sides of the “equation” – I have but one query for the NDA, and one for the GoI. If indeed Mr Modi did rescue Gujaratis only, then my question is : aren’t the other victims deserving of rescue? As a Maharashtrian Indian, am I now to be treated differently from Gujaratis Indians? It pains me to write these words, but in the light of what I have read online, this is a pertinent query. We are all Indians and are equal in front of any State or Central Government, and this blatant discrimination – if true – is disturbing.  Very, very, very, very, very, very, very, very disturbing. And if this is false, why hasnt anyone denied this and clarified with an equal amount visibility? I certainly haven’t read any rebuttals!

Narendra Modi lands in Uttarakhand, flies out with 15,000 Gujaratis

Uttarakhand: Narendra Modi targeted by Yashwant Sinha

This, sir, is not acceptable. This way lies anarchy: should residents of Maharashtra now start looking to their State Government above the Indian Nation? Is a state more important? Should MP domiciles start looking after MP-ites only, to the exclusion of all else? This is just not acceptable. Till this happened, I was looking forward to the US response in case Modi takes over as PM… their snootiness towards Modi would have to take a back seat! It was a tantalisingly delicious prospect and dream of meeting those holier-than-thou geniuses in the US of A. Not anymore; I am no longer with Mr Modi or the NDA. Not after this Gujarati-only approach. I am only an Indian : my language and my state-hood are not in the least important. I demand equality: and give equality. It is also my right!

THE SECOND SIDE
Coming to Mr Gandhi and the GoI, first of all – how has this much touted visit by Gandhi (which was after the Modi visit) helped? Was it a genuine help effort, or an attempt to stem the slide caused by Modi and his Gujaratisms? What practical good was achieved? Answer: 

Page on Bhaskar

ITBP DG denies officers evicted from Gauchar mess to accommodate Rahul Gandhi, says they were relocated

And the DG of ITBP says Rahul Gandhi’s security was of paramount importance! More important than even saving lives, is it? And the officers were not removed, they were relocated!!!!! Pray tell me what is the difference? And removal of officers – howsoever temporary – must have caused some problems. That is simple logic. 

So, my dear GOI, tell me – a simple, powerless citizen of India – is Rahul Gandhi more important than saving thousands of lives? And how is it that a rank-outsider like Modi can just waltz into a disaster area unannounced and without clearance and organise a Rambo-style rescue? Insofar as Uttarakhand tragedy is concerned – outside of the Armed Forces, Uttarakhand State Government and Central Government – everyone else is persona-non-grata. How did Modi pull it off? Why did Rahul’s security demand vacation of a rescue camp in one of the worst natural disaster hit areas in India???? Who gave them the bloody guts to do that?  That means there is no control of any kind: every man for himself, is it? What a positively fabulous way of running a government! Awesome: you have my personal congratulations! 

That leaves me with 2 options: on one side, a party that fields a Help-Gujarati-Only man as a prime candidate; and on the other side a party who places personal security over and above the convenience of people engaged in rescue work, a party that mismanages this whole sick episode…

Who do I choose?  Maikadaa chunoon – yaa “Uske” ghar jaaon?

Maikadaa ==> bar
Us: in this example above: I have taken it to mean “the other woman”

Both are dangerous!!!!

Ai gham-e-zindagi kuch to de mashvaraa
Ek taraf uskaa ghar ek taraf maikadaa
main kahaa jaaoon hotaa nahi faislaa
Ek taraf uska ghar ek taraf maikadaa…

Getting Back To 8% Plus: A Chimera? Or A Realisable Dream?

Published June 27, 2013 by vishalvkale

This is the second part of the article http://reflectionsvvk.blogspot.in/2013/06/the-indian-growth-engine-hobsons-choice.html

eruse any newpaper, online business site dedicated to India (or any other for that matter) – you will find a set of reactions and analysis posted using the words “urgent need for kick-starting reforms” or “Indian Problems are structural in nature”; apart from a rare article in business newspapers, and the odd analytical article in Business Magazines, few – if any – deal with this at any length. Reams are written on Current Account Deficit, Rupee’s Free Fall, FII redemption pressures, Policy Stasis; the assumption is that certain policy matters, if corrected, can get us back on track again. Accordingly, our political classes come out with plans and schemes to attract FDI into the country by various means; as if the answer lies in that alone.

What use is a policy that cannot be implemented fully, whose benefits do not reach the people? Furthermore, what use is a policy that attracts FDI in non-core sectors, and ignores the problems facing India’s core sector? What use is a policy that does nothing to encourage domestic capital formation? What use is a policy that does not improve the business environment? Granted that FDI will lead to an immediate relief; it will make things slightly more comfortable for India. Granted that policy measures in a nation growing at 5% – which is far higher a rate than the developed world will serve to attract capital; but this does nothing to correct the structural issues that are facing the economy. The danger of a relapse will remain. 

The real problems facing the nation are shortage of skilled manpower; shortage of electricity; shortage of good motorable roads; shortage of good affordable healthcare in the rural regions; insufficient internet access speeds; poor agricultural productivity; among others. What has been done – leave alone done – what intent has been stated to meet and solve these problems? Nothing. Precisely nothing. Electricity Projects are mired in Land Acquisition Problems; Coal is mired in  corruption allegations; ditto Oil; there is no focus on primary education and secondary education – which is also deeply mired in corruption allegations; Road projects are at a virtual standstill and beset with huge corruption, leading to even life threats for some decent IAS officers… in fact, virtually every significant area of the core sector has been shaken to the core with corruption allegations and lack of access to funds due to Land problems, water sharing etc issues. How anyone expects a return to those halcyon days of 8-10% growth is beyond me. 

Those lovely dreamy days and frenetic growth were in a period when almost the entire emerging markets were experiencing fast growth. The Global atmosphere was one of low interest rates, optimism, global surplus and newly opened markets with the attendant enthusiasm they brought into the global stew. This is clearly absent today; the global scenario is depressed and market after market is showing regressive tendencies. In this changed atmosphere, the requirement is a sea change in approach. And this is quite clearly missing from the scenario in India. Unless we do something radically different to change the prevailing atmosphere – confidence is not going to return. And radical changes don’t happen often; the only realistic path is to attend to the serious challenges mentioned above and get back on a gradual recovery path. The alternative is now not an option anymore- with each and every sector hit – and severely hit – by scam allegations in the past 4-5 years, rebuilding confidence over the long term, and attracting domestic capital as well as stable FDI as opposed to short-term FII investments is just about the only path ahead for us. 

India has now acquired a justified reputation of being a nation of scams; there can be no argument against that. Add to this the real policy issues – Fertiliser and Oil Subsidy, Land Reforms, Labour Reforms and Police Reforms. This is a deadly combination that is throttling real growth and market performance. The Government has shown no intent on tackling these very serious and vexing issues plaguing the economy; what is worse is that there is a palpable lack of a national dialogue on these issues in the Media. No one seems willing to bell the cat – even in the media. It is not enough to state “structural problems” – please identify those problems, give a solution/s, and don’t hide behind the words “political hot potato”! Does their being politically difficult mean that should not be cured? Try that in a disease in your own body! Try and ignore any disease like cancer – or even a fever! The person who does so will like as not be in an ICU 7 times out of 10! This is the perfect corollary – these structural issues have now become cancerous – and need attending to with affirmative action, not glib dialogue. It is because things are tough that we have highly paid IAS officers and experiences politicians to deal with such matters. And yet, the Media, The People, The Officers and The Politicians choose to ignore these matters, and concentrate on frankly short-term measures that will alleviate the immediate problem. 

Yes, short term measures are important – if you are a cancer patient who has been bitten by a snake, the need of the hour is treatment for snake-bite. Similarly, to alleviate CAD pressures leading to BOP problems, short term measures are needed urgently – but that does not mean we ignore the other, more pressing structural issues. Unfortunately, we are treating only the snake-bite, and ignoring the cancer. How sustainable is this model going to be? Not very. 

Even the people are in a stupor – witness this article : http://reflectionsvvk.blogspot.in/2013/06/usne-kiyaa-he-did-it-he-did-it.html.  They are either mute spectators, or willing collaborators in the dance of death that is the game of corruption. In the next article, I shall examine the causes of this stupor, and look at possible solutions to this quagmire… an ambitious task, but at least I can make an attempt

Usne Kiyaa… He Did It… He Did it…

Published June 26, 2013 by vishalvkale

Usne Kiyaa… He Did It… He Did it…
That sound familiar? No? Well, it should. That is what every media vehicle and every citizen scream every single day, Monday ho yaa Sunday. Every day, without fail, regardless of occasion, we can hear this in some form or the other. It is a ritualistic utterance in some cases; insincere in others; and unfortunately sincere in some… 
I am talking about the response to the challenges and problems facing India. From governance to corruption: for every problem, we have a staple response. Usne Kiyaa! He Did It! It Wasnt Me! I Didnt Do It! He Did It! It Was That Person! And lo and behold, the focus of the entire nation shifts to the evil uncultured political class,or the government officers, or the policemen, or… but no. It was never us; we didnt do it. No. Nope. Never. Nada. We are innocent babes, pure as the driven snow. 
Now take a step back and observe. Let us observe corruption from afar – and not that piffling and trivial 10-buck corruption that we encounter ever day. I am talking big bucks. Let us take any major scam: observe how normal everyday Indians act as mute spectators to ongoing corruption. For example, when balance sheets are inflated – as in Satyam – it is painfully obvious that quite a few respectable normal citizens would have been aware – finance managers; clerks etc. When inflated subsidy bills are prepared, again a chain of normal people must have been involved; the people who made the delivery challans, bills, claims etc. For bad roads, an entire chain – starting from the bitumen provider, the granite quarry, engineers of the construction firm, government engineers,  clerks etc would have to be aware. For Land Scams, the clerks of the office as well as others in the chan have to be aware. For any scam to successfully operate – it is a given that the silence of the normal man is also an unwitting cause.  It is also a given that any number of junior functionaries has to be involved for it to be carried forward. 
Who is responsible? Only the Government? Only the crooks? Only the political class? What about the clerk who made the fake challan? What about the sales channel that provided third-grade bitumen? What about the guy who made the balance sheets? What about the clerks in his department, some of who must have realised? What about the guy who made those lovely excel sheets?
Usne Kiyaa???? He Did It? Really? Is our moral compass so bloody skewed that we cannot see where the normal Indian has gone wrong? We routinely offer bribed to cops, to government clerks and officials – even without being asked for. We agree to give – aah – envelopes to important officers without even a twinge, a tweak of our conscience. Dont we know what is inside the envelope? Dont we know that the material is third rate? Dont we know that M/s XYZ Pvt Ltd has only been supplied 4 consignments? Dont we know that the profit cannot possibly be as high as claimed, as we are the people who prepare those damned daily reports, monitor costs and sales etc? Dont we know that the bloody building has a height of 48 feet plus-minus 6 feet, and therefore the claim of 78 feet of insulated wire is just crap? What bullshit are we talking about? Usne Kiyaa? He Did It?





Humne Kiyaa! We Did It! It Was Us! All Of Us! We Are Guilty!

As I always say – Jaago, Sonewaalon~!
Published June 22, 2013 by vishalvkale

<a class="qlink qtext_editor_link_text" data-link-delete="http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/india/BrahMos-cant-be-intercepted-in-next-20-years-Pillai/articleshow/20628352.cms?utm_source=twitter.com&utm_medium=referral&utm_campaign=timesofindia&quot; data-link-text="BrahMos can't be intercepted in next 20 years: Pillai” href=”http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/india/BrahMos-cant-be-intercepted-in-next-20-years-Pillai/articleshow/20628352.cms?utm_source=twitter.com&utm_medium=referral&utm_campaign=timesofindia&#8221; id=”qlink_d8yub69d1f”>BrahMos can’t be intercepted in next 20 years: Pillai

The enclosed article showcases Indo-Russian strategic partnership – as well as clearly establishes Indian capabilities; capabilities which have no need of independent proof, given that we have placed a lander on the moon! It also underlines the mutual trust and confidence each party has in the other; something which is sorely missing from the India-US partnership.

The Brahmos project, or the 5G fighter project are defence projects that are state-of-the-art, participation in which enhances Indian prestige, develops & strengthens Indian skills and give its armed forces cutting edge technology – while leveraging skills in both countries for competitive advantage. Another important point to be noted is that both countries get the technology almost at the same time: it is not in the nature of a handout from a superiour nation to a developing nation.

This is precisely what the USA is loathe to do; and expects us to respond to their overtures! If the USA is serious about engaging India in a strategic dialogue – which I very seriously doubt – then they would do well to identify areas where complementary skills can be leveraged to mutual benefit. Otherwise its runs the very real risk of stagnation in what was once a promising relationship.

What is required is a mindset change in US politicians; they need to stop viewing India as less of a supermarket where they can offload their excess production, and more of a partner in business – which can bring to the table complementary skills that can be leveraged to mutual benefit. A business relationship is give-and-take; you bring goods to be market as per needs, sell them and move on to the next day; a partnership entails ensuring the other partner develops his or her own skill sets; between nations it implies prestige, equality and trust.

Unfortunately, there is nothing that has been placed on the table by the USA that even remotely implies trust, prestige, equality and development. Therein lies the problem: to them, the nation south of China is “India Supermarket, Inc. “…

And by the time USA wakes up to this reality….India – a deeply proud and independent India – will have charted its own course, away from the USA; signs of wich are already extant! And that is the sad part – that 2 democracies will move away from each other due to the myopic policies of one!

Are we our own greatest enemies?

Published June 16, 2013 by vishalvkale

Ancient History
From its Ancient History, India can learn Confidence. This is the land that gave the world innumerable scientists, inventions and discoveries; if we can do it once – we can do it again. This is the land that was known as the sone ki chidiya; the land that was quite literally an international trading powerhouse. As I said – if we can do it once, we can do it again. This is the land Charak, of Sushrut, Baudhayan, Kanad, Aryabhat, Varahamihir, Brahmagupt, Patanjali, Bhaskaracharya. This is also the land of ChandraGupt Maurya, Ashok, Rajaraj Chola, Vikramaditya, Harshavardhan. This is the land that has given birth to great kingdoms and great thinkers alike; if we can do it once- we can do it again. 

India can learn openness in Trade; this is what defined Ancient India, and indeed Medieval India as well. There is documented evidence of trading outposts outside India in locations as far away as in Central Asia – and this is before 3000BC at least. Trade is what made India famous across the Earth; Trade is what defined us – not military might. This is a theme that is repeated across our 9500 year documented history; more of it later

India can learn the virtues of education and the benefits of promoting research and science. It is a documented fact that scientific achievements dropped off after 1100 – 1200 AD as the sciences and literature both lost official partonage; a cursory look at both the fields in the period 1200 – 1500 AD is mute testimony. The temporary revival of literature due to official patronage during Mughal rule is another proof of this, 

Medieval India
The recurring theme of military might raises its head here again; India can learn the virtues of having a powerful military presence from its medieval experiences. Our open nature laid us wide open to invasion – and invade they did. In large numbers; some stayed back, and built upon existing strengths – while some came to loot – like the British swines, Abdali or Ghazni. 

India can learn to stick together as Indians rather than side with outsiders – I am deliberately using this more offensive term than the soft-sounding word “unity”. We lost during medieval times due in large part to the fact that some idiot from India sided with rank outsiders, and stabbed their own people in the back. Again, this is a recurring theme, as we shall see later. 

From Medieval India, Modern India can learn tolerance; for it is here that the greatest threat to our established secular values, and the true power of Sanatan Dharm manifest themselves. Earlier, when Jewish settlements were coming up, when early Christians were settling up, when the first Muslim areas came up in the North-West – the rulers were either Buddhists or fellow Sanatan dharmis. Our secular and wonderfully resilient character and internal strength came to the fore during 1200 – 1500 AD, and more strongly during Aurangzeb”s time – and The Goa Inquisition during the colonial era. This is a valuable lesson for Modern India – the virtues of moderation and tolerance. 

Colonial India
As I noted above; in this period we find the recurring themes or Military Might and Unity raise their head. A weakened and divided – but economically powerful and culturally rich land was no match for the military might of an impoverished and backward nation like Britain. The arguments of Industrial revolution does not hold water; it is the benefits of loot from India that ignited the industrial revolution in the west. That is established history.

 The combination of scientific degeneration and internal strife created havoc in a period when coincidentally the exact reverse was happening in a backward and torn Europe. It is one of the most enduring tragedies that a backward and amoral people could overcome so easily one of the most advanced civilizations on Earth – we, who have had 9500 years of uninterrupted development behind us, could lose so easily – leading to our next lesson : A world view and awareness of developments. We were blind to the world, complacent in our status as the most advanced people and the richest… the world stepped on the gas pedal… and we were asleep. Avoid Complacency is the lesson for us!

It is colonial India that teaches us the power of collective action – which holds powerful lessons for us. It is colonial India that teaches us the that India’s greatest enemy is not the outsider – but the bloody insider who cooperates with the rapists and enemies. This recurring theme appears at its ugliest in this period, with massive repercussions for Modern India… but that is another story, to be taken up on my blog in another article…

Modern India
Only one lesson here: that Modern India can and should learn from its history. Tolerance is the way of life here; the reverse lead to one Pakistan, and another Bangladesh. In the Indian Subcontinent the only way forward is religious tolerance, cultural tolerance – and this is a lesson that should be heeded by all three of us children of The Land Of Aryavarta – India, Pakistan and Bangladesh. Unity, and economic trade mean nothing without military might; India needs all three. 

Modern India is living proof of how division can lead to destruction. Throughout time, our greatest enemy has always been the covert insider who sides with the outsider; in Modern India – we have an insider that is openly siding with the outsider. Pakistan and India can do wonders if we bury the hatchet; we, the children of Aryavarta could learn that. Our greatest enemy continues to be the insider… nothing has changed even after 9500 years. Now more so than ever, we need to be tolerant, united, open to trade, focussed on education and health. And above all of this, given that a section of Aryavarta is now openly an enemy – namely, Pakistan – now more than ever, we need to be militarily strong. Our history teaches us this. But is anyone listening? From the deepening contours of intolerance is rising the fear of history repeating itself; now more than ever, India – the eldest daughter and heir-apparent to the Golden land of Aryavarta – needs to be tolerant, magnanimous and humane; as Aryavarta and its children always were. That is our defining characteristic  that is our USP; that is our real power. That is what made India the most sought-after jewel in History. If we can do it once – we can do it again. 

Are we our own greatest enemies? Food for thought.

The Indian Growth Engine: A Hobson’s Choice

Published June 14, 2013 by vishalvkale

The recent news on the economic front has brought little cheer with IIP numbers, Current Account Deficit, Inflation, Exchange Rates all being dissatisfactory. Market sentiment continues to be abysmal, and charges of misgovernment abound. There seems to be little cheer on the global horizon either with Europe in the doldrums, BR(I)CS being questioned, and the grand-daddy of them all (USA) having serious problems of its own. This, in a nutshell, is the scenario that confront our policy makers,  planners, corporates and the common man


The reaction from at least the policy makers is clear, as is evident from the Hon. FM’s statements of recent days: FDI! Attract foreign inflows! The reaction of corporates is also crystal clear, at least externally – wait’n’watch. And the common man is way too occupied in meeting his own targets of meals for the family 2 times a day to worry overmuch about anything. And, at the end of it all, no one is actually doing anything, in reality hoping that this is a cyclical downturn, and the wheel of time will bring the economy churning back to full speed in the due fullness of time. 

Well, I hope they are right and I am wrong; that would be great, for it means minimal damage. But my analysis tells me otherwise. First, there are serious structural issues in the Indian Economy that are the major hindering factors. These problems – unconscionably high Fertilizer and Oil Subsidy bills, policy uncertainty, investment slowdown and flight of capital, fiscal deficit, infrastructure issues, project delays at both clearance and implementation stages etc – are not ones that will correct without affirmative action. Therein lies the rub; and all this is being played against a backdrop of corruption.

The action that is being taken currently is far from affirmative – we have been hearing talk of breakthrough reforms for time immemorial with little or no actual substance in them. Yes, the fuel price correction was a step in the right direction; but the vehicle of reforms got stuck in a traffic jam after that step. There is nothing concrete in evidence, or in the pipeline (going by news reports I have read) that indicates a genuine series of steps that tackle the structural issues relating to the economy listed above. Let alone political hot-potatoes like Fertilizer Subsidy – which is admittedly easier to talk about than actually reduce; even some of the simpler, easier structural issues lie unattended. The biggest pity is that we have in power tried and tested politicians whose skill at running an economy  is well-known by all; furthermore, given all that has transpired these past 2 years, they have nothing to lose – and consequently everything to gain – by taking hard decisions. And yet, we have a stasis in the overall politico-economic scenario. 

The issues I am referring to are policy uncertainty; flight of local capital; project approval delays; project implementation problems and corruption – all leading to investment slowdown. For investment to improve, sentiment (expectations of growth, ROI etc) will have to be positive; for it to be positive – we have to give a certainty to investors in terms of climate, and lack of hurdles. In short sentiment will have to improve if we are to get back to those halcyon days of 8% – 10% growth. And for growth, you require capital. First off, any economy that is dependent on foreign capital is not exactly a dream economy; we should be asking ourselves what can we do to  ensure local capital stays inside, and is used to generate local strengths and growth. As regards foreign capital – why should it come to India in these times, with the attendant political risk it entails – of which we have seen plenty of evidence in the past year alone? Furthermore, the lack of clarity  in policy matters – think of FDI in retail – is a further dampener. 

We can thus look at this in 2 parts – foreign and domestic capital; or to simplify matters – we can look at steps to be taken to ensure investment climate improves – which brings us right back to the issues highlighted above. For the nature of capital is such that each  – foreign or domestic – will flow to the area of least resistance and optimal returns. And for that to happen, we will have to ensure policy clarity, remove implementation hurdles and reduce red tape. 

Much has been written about policy clarity in the financial press; almost too much. But on implementation, there is little that is written that deals with the core of the issue. And that is the true sad story that is sweeping across India – Cobrapost exposed the underbelly of the Indian Banking sector, embroiling Axis, ICICI, HDFC and IndusInd banks (among others) in the resulting furore; the recent drug scandals that have rocked Ranbaxy, a slight google search will reveal other drug companies facing some objection or the other, with Wochardt, Dabur India, Hospira (to name but a few) receiving alerts or being placed on watch. Telecom is yet another case in point, which needs no details – having been covered threadbare in the news. Mining has also been exposed as a hotbed of corruption and crime. Connect the dots – and the picture that is forming is not a happy or indeed a comfortable one. All these – and more – and going to ensure that there is a negative pull on the India brand image and global sentiment. Combine this scenario with the policy stasis that is in evidence- and you are looking at trouble with a capital T. 

Now take all of this, and add to this pot-pourri the top-heavy nature of India’s development with the poorer sections of society having been bypassed in the growth from the 1980s onwards – The per capita income of the bottom 20% of India’s population has not changed (as a percentage share) since 1978. That means, the bottom 20% of our population has not benefited at all from our economic boom. This is also confirmed by consumption patterns: with the consumption by the bottom 20% of the population being static @ between 0 – 1 growth%, in complete variance with the 3% growth registered by the top layers. Not only are the interventions targeted at the poor not reaching them; there is also an absence of opportunities for them to grow out of their hopeless situation in terms of healthcare, education and other HDI parameters, where we are among the poorest in the world. Unless this latent potential is tapped, real growth is well-nigh impossible; but that is another story, which I shall connect up in the second part of this article.

One could almost be forgiven for assuming that we are looking at India in a state of implosion – were it not for the activities of the pillars of modern India as identified by Shashi Tharoor in his landmark work “The Great Indian Novel”. I refer to the Media and The Judiciary specifically, whose activism has brought all of the above cases to the public eye. 

This is the backdrop in its entirety; in this scenario, it can be readily seen that there is really no choice in front of the powers that be; in other words, a  Hobson’s choice. Steps to tackle all of these problems have to be taken; uncertainty, policy matters, corruption etc everything has to be dealt with. Working on any one parameter alone will not suffice – since the threat of exposure will remain; the hindrances to implementation will remain; the problem of bribery and corruption will remain. This is bound to act as a dampener – as corruption makes implementation of projects cumbersome. The increasing activism of US Government on their companies’ bribe-giving world-wide is a case in point. To improve sentiment the requirement is making business easy in India, which will not happen unless corruption is tackled on a war footing. Not anymore; not after sector after sector of the economy is embroiled in controversy. That will only further capital flight – which already seems to have begun, if you take into consideration investments by Indian groups abroad. 

For, if the hope is that we can kindle real growth by tinkering around with some issues without addressing the real problems in their entirety, then this is a stillborn hope. Without addressing both sides of the equation – namely, policy stasis and implementation – we will not be able to take Brand India to where it was 5-7 years ago. The reason is evident- for in those halcyon days of hectic growth, we did not have the additional baggage of crippling scandals rocking just about every sector of the economy. Those were the days of a virgin territory, if you will; this is a luxury we dont have anymore. And neither can we realistically expect to shove these exposures under the carpet and hope that things will continue as before – our active pillars of Media and Judiciary will ensure that a percentage – hopefully a large percentage – of unsavory deals will get ruthlessly exposed. Furthermore, we cannot expect the global anti-corruption flair (esp US Govt) to wane. That is why this is a Hobson’s Choice – we have to look at both stasis as well as implementation hurdles…

In the next part, I will take a deeper look at the implementation aspects; and why it is fallacious to blame our political class for everything… and why passing the Lokpal bill alone will not be the panacea it promises to be; and why the left-behind people need to be looked at. Lokpal is vital; but it is just one in a series of steps… 

Pride and Prejudice… The Indian Cultural Scenario

Published June 11, 2013 by vishalvkale

This is the 10th article on the culture series

India is an ancient land with a rich heritage going back several millennia, a resplendent artistic and cultural tradition, a history with several glorious and resplendent chapters and a richness and uniqueness of the land and its people who have stayed together despite many challenges. These are known and accepted matters internationally- for which we do not require any approval or acceptance from anyone.

And yet, a look at the contemporary landscape of Modern Urban India would belie the above statement in its totality – the penchant of the Urban Indian of fawning over western symbols to the detriment of our own being a painful symptom of this. Anything to do with western recognition in any field is hyped up – there are innumerable examples across the cultural landscape. Be it The Booker, or be it the Oscar – any success in these is a ticket to instant recognition. There is nothing wrong with this by itself – but at the core lies a fundamental dichotomy that is strange at best, and reprehensible at worst. We Indians love to wax eloquent on our heritage, and yet pay little attention to national Indian awards. The problem is not that the western symbols are hyped up; the challenge is that Indian awards, functions and symbols are played down, and not given their due importance in the eyes of the public. The same Indian who extolls our culture and heritage, is the one who downplays these – and that is the dichotomous behaviour. This is the pull, the allure of the west, and its blind aping in  India. This is not limited to the artistic scene alone; but has spread to nearly every corner of our society, like a cancer.  Let us take movies and books as cases in study

The Indian Mumbai movie industry outsells Hollywood quite comfortably in terms of annual ticket sale, and has now acquired a following across the globe, spanning Pakistan, The Middle East, Africa, Singapore, Malasia, Thialand etc – with an increasing presence in European countries: and even the USA. The net result is ticket sales that outsell anyone else, and a global footprint that exceeds 3 Billion in ticket sales, with a covered population of more than 4 -4.5 Billion people across the globe. This is by no means or scale a small achievement. 

The point is not that the western movies and functions are to be avoided, or to denigrate them, or indeed to compare. The point is the due place to our own internal products in movies which currently they dont get. Cover and covet the Oscars by all means; but give a similar importance, pride and prestige to our own internal awards and functions – which should not be neglected. It is this lack of pride in our achievements that is the root of the problem.

The point also is that our movies do not need the stamp of acceptance from any culture or nation; they have acquired a momentum and fan following of their own across the world. In the words of Shah Rukh Khan, our movies are the only ones to have withstood the onslaught of Hollywood. Given our movies their due place. This is a statement echoed by Javed Akhtar as well : “Hollywood is such a powerful film industry that it has ruined film industries of the world. Wherever Hollywood films reach, the original film industry of that nation got ruined, except India. Our film industry is flourishing be it Tamil and Telugu films,” the 67-year-old said here at the music launch ofYe Khula Aasman. “Our films are showcased in around one 30 nations abroad. The number of nations that view Hindi films is increasing and this is not an ordinary thing,” said Akhtar.”We have made some good and bad films. We have made some excellent films as well. I think Indian cinema is at such a point that the future can only be bright and in another 10 years it will reach great heights,” said Akhtar, who has penned songs for films like Mr.India, Tezaab, 1942: A Love Story, Dil Chahta Hai andRefugee.


Unfortunately, you wouldnt know it from the reportage of our media – which is ultimately derived from the impressions and views of the readers. These, and other similar facts, go unreported, or get carried in small columns somewhere; whereas even the smallest, most ludicruous of achievements in the west, especially in the USA and UK get reams upon reams of media coverage. It is this prejudiced coverage, and assumptions that is the root of the problem at hand. The unsaid – and at times explicitly stated contention – that they are better and that their awards are global and ours are regional is not borne out by the facts. It is a sad lack of pride in our achievements and a prejudice that is clearly in evidence. I shall go into the details of the reasons of this behaviour in a later article – as there is much that needs coverage and detailing. At this point, suffice it to state that this behaviour represents a collosal failure for us, and is reflective of a deep-seated complex within us as a society – in addition to being a total failure in marketing our Film Industry. 


This can also be seen across the length and breadth of the cultural spectrum: let us consider books. We have a rich tradition of writing spanning millennia – but you wouldn’t know it from a visit to our book stores, where I can – and have- procured a copy of Alberuni’s India (reviewed on my main blog) , but cannot get my hands on a copy of The RugVed, or any Upanishad, or any Puran. I can spot an entire rack of western classics – but no Indian classic is in evidence. I can even spot Islamic and Christian religious literature on occasion – but no Indian works. Not even the famous Abhigyaan Shakuntalam. (The Strand Book Stall Fort Mumbai is a notable exception – respect, sir). I can find Shakespeare – but no Tagore. And if I cannot find Tagore, then to expect that Neeraj, Suman, Kaka Hathrasi will be present is being optimistic in the extreme. 

In the literary sphere, we are still on a learning curve – as I have noted in my earlier articles. That accounts for lesser sales and a lesser fan-following, which is in keeping with  a growing industry. Thus, greater visibility of western books is only to be expected. Curiously, it is this growing trade which is giving a fillip to its internal image by showing 2 bestseller lists: Indian, and Western. Furthermore, the explosion of literature in India in the recent past in all genres- fiction as well as non-fiction has brought this industry centre-stage. 

And it is this trade that is showing signs of a revival in pride, and abandonment of its long-held prejudice. This is evident in the increasing shelf-space to Indian writing, and the increasing fan-following of Indian writers. What is now required is a revival of the vernacular literature; but that is a different article entirely, to be taken up later. But the worries still remain – the absence of interest in our classics, and the attendant interest in western classics is just one such example.

The same can be spotted across the broad spectrum of urban life – especially metropolitan life spanning Television Serials, movies, books etc. This manifest fawning over western culture, icons and symbols has deep-seated roots, as we shall see in the next article. It is a matter of routine statement that you come across, advocating western awards on various items as proof of having arrived; as I said there is nothing wrong in  it. The issue is the disdain for local awards and achievements, which are not hyped to extent that the others are – and this is frequently when the item that gets an international award portrays India in a bad light, examples of which are in  abundance. 

This manifest lack of a pride in ourselves, and a realisation that we are a culturally unique nation that has held its own against a severe cultural onslaught which has overrun others is the fundamental problem. This has reasons -as we shall see later. But it is this discounting of our numbers, and of our cultural influence which far exceeds our borders and our realisation which is a major stumbling block in our path. 

For pride is not just a word; it is a way of doing things; it has practical ramifications, and a potential for realisation of self-worth. Prejudice prevents us from seeing our potential, of our ability to influence the world and make India a better place for ourselves; while pride opens doors for us – so long as we are in control of that pride, so long as it doesnt go to our heads…